Preventing or Reducing Fruit on Ornamental Trees and Shrubs
“Nuisance fruit” is a concern for many people including homeowners, landscapers, and park and city officials. The fruits and seeds of some trees and shrubs, such as buckthorn, mulberry, persimmon, and (female) ginkgo are unsightly, smelly, and have the potential to be a hazard when they fall on sidewalks, driveways, and other areas in a landscape. Foliar sprays are available to reduce or eliminate undesirable fruit development on ornamental landscape plants, but factors such as timing, plant stresses, environmental conditions, and lack of thorough applications may make complete control impossible. Results will vary with each chemical designed to eliminate fruit.
FACTORS TO CONSIDER BEFORE SPRAYING
Trees and shrubs are usually selected for landscape use based on their ornamental features, such as spring flowers, fall color, and fruit. All trees and shrubs produce some type of flowers and fruit, whether inconspicuous or showy. Fruit production is part of the plant’s natural development. A plant that produces a large amount of fruit may be a desirable ornamental feature or be used to feed wildlife. Despite the value of a flowering and fruiting plant, some people consider spent flowers and fruit that fall undesirable litter. There are several methods to remove fruit or prevent fruiting. Hand-removing spent flowers or small fruits will work on a small tree, but is not a practical solution for large trees or extensive plantings. Chemical or hormone-type sprays are a more practical method, but spraying your tree can be a costly and time-consuming venture. Consider the following before you decide to spray:
Amount of fruit production. The amount of fruit a plant can produce varies from year to year. Many plants will produce heavily one year and lighter the next. Insect, disease, and damage to flower blooms can reduce fruit production. Hand-removal of spent flowers is one way to eliminate unwanted fruit.
Plant removal. If maintenance is a problem, does the plant warrant keeping? Attempting to remove fruit will become a yearly expense of time and money. When all options have been considered, plant removal may be the best alternative, and replace with a plant that holds its fruit (i.e., some hawthorns and crabapples).
Size of tree. If the tree is too large to do the work yourself, you may have to hire a licensed professional to achieve adequate results.
Timing of application. Whether you hire a professional or do the work yourself, it is essential to spray at the proper time for best results. The “window of opportunity” varies with the species and cultivars (varieties) of a plant.
WHEN AND HOW TO SPRAY
Timing. The window of opportunity for chemical or hormone-type sprays is during flowering before fruit set, usually from flower buds to the full bloom stage. It is imperative that you spray at this time for chemicals to be most effective on the flower bud. Spraying before or after flowers results in wasted time and money.
Temperature. Hormone-type sprays are influenced by weather conditions. Daytime temperatures at the time of application should be between 60oF and 95oF for best results.
Use correct concentrations. A concentration too low can increase fruit set. Excess hormone applications will cause damage to the plant.
Spray stress-free plants. Plants being treated should be healthy and vigorous. Spraying plants under stress can cause additional damage to a plant. The chemical ethephon, used to stop fruiting, breaks down into a natural plant hormone, ethylene. Plants under stress from drought, high temperatures, insect and disease problems, or environmental stress, such as compacted soils, poor drainage, or improper pH will produce ethylene. Too much ethylene can be harmful to plants, causing injury symptoms such as leaf scorch, stem damage, or defoliation, further weakening the condition of the plant.
Chemicals are available to reduce or eliminate fruit set on ornamental trees and shrubs. Check with local nurseries and garden centers — spraying cannot guarantee 100% effectiveness. Follow specific label directions for application rates and safety information.
- Florel® Fruit Eliminator by Monteray, active ingredient: ethephon
- Fruitone or App-L-Set, active ingredient: Naphthalene acid (NAA)
- Carbaryl (trade name Sevin) — this insecticide is harmful to bees
Choose plants that have seedless cultivars. A true seedless variety is the only guaranteed method to eliminate fruit. Below are a few non-fruiting or seedless cultivars available at nurseries. Not all plants listed are recommended for the home landscape.
Fraxinus americana - ‘Skyline’, White ‘Autumn Applause’, ‘Autumn Purple’, ‘Rosehill’ Fraxinus excelsior - European Ash, ‘Hessei’ Fraxinus pennsylvanica - Green Ash, ‘Marshall Seedless’, ‘Newport’, ‘Pratmore’, ‘Summit’
Phellodendron amurense - Amur Corktree, ‘Macho’
Populus deltoides - Cottonwood, use male species only, ‘Siouxland’
Malus sp. - Crabapple, ‘Spring Snow’ (fruitless, but fire blight and apple scab susceptible)
Ginkgo biloba - Ginkgo, use male plants only, ‘Fastigiata’ (columnar; seedless) Honeylocust Gleditsia triacanthos f. inermis - Thornless
‘Fairview’, ‘Green Glory’, ‘Imperial’, ‘Moraine’, ‘Shademaster’, ‘Skyline’, ‘Sunburst’ Horse chestnut Aesculus x carnea - Ruby
‘Briotii’ (nearly fruitless) Aesculus hippocastanum - Horse chestnut, ‘Baumannii’
Acer rubrum - Red Maple, ‘Autumn Flame’, ‘Northwood’ Acer saccharinum - Silver Maple, ‘Beebe Cutleaf Weeping’, ‘Silver Queen’, ‘Skinneri’ Acer x freemanii - ‘Celzam’, ‘Jeffersred’ (nearly seedless)
Refer to the Illinois Urban Pest Management Handbook (University of Illinois Cooperative Extension Service) for a complete listing of chemical recommendations. Use pesticides safely and wisely; read and follow label directions. The pesticide information presented in this publication is current with federal and state regulations. The user is responsible for determining that the intended use is consistent with the label of the product being used. The information given here is for educational purposes only. Reference to commercial products or trade names is made with the understanding that no discrimination is intended and no endorsement made by The Morton Arboretum.
- Planting Trees and Shrubs 49%
Trees can be obtained from the nursery in many forms—bare root, container-grown, balled and burlapped, or dug by tree spade. Transplanting can be successful with all forms. Always put extra effort into the planting process to ensure a good start...
- Invasive Trees, Shrubs, and Vines 49%
Identifying Invasive Plants When settlers began gardening, they had a constant struggle to keep the natural ecosystem from invading and overwhelming their small cultivated patches. Today, humans have so altered the Midwest landscape that the...
- Low Growing Deciduous Shrubs (under 5 feet) 48%
Generally grow up to 5 feet tall, easy to maintain in proper scale Essentially, a low-growing woody plant that branches at its base Lose their leaves in fall (deciduous) Recommended for the Midwest on the basis of ornamental value,...
- Intermediate Sized Evergreens (6-20 feet) 47%
Growing 6-20 feet tall, they retain foliage year-round, and soften structural edges around foundations, under windows, at corners, or against walls. Like mid-sized shrubs, they create structure and depth in mixed plantings, and provide backdrop for...
- Low Growing Evergreens (generally less than 6 feet) 47%
Generally growing less than 6 feet, these shrubs screen unwanted objects and views all year, can be used to stabilize slopes or embankments, and add color to winter landscapes. They come in a variety of shapes and sizes, from mounded to upright to...
- Intermediate Sized Deciduous Shrubs (5-8 feet) 45%
Intermediate-sized Deciduous Shrubs for the Home Landscape Generally grow 5-8 feet tall Plants with multiple stems arising from a common crown at ground level or single-stemmed plants that begin branching at a point near the ground Lose their...